Illinois Right to Life Committee
Roe Needs To Be Rocked
Roe needs to be rocked November 10, 2004 Editor: The premise of Cindy Richard's November 10th
article "Emboldened GOP ready to rock Roe" is that legal abortion is safe, but
making abortion illegal would lead to women dying from unsafe abortions. She quotes
a statistic that 193 women died from illegal abortions in the U.S. in 1965. This
number had fallen to 39 in 1972, the year prior to Roe v. Wade. At that time
abortion supporters were falsely claiming that 5,000-10,000 women were dying annually from
"back-alley" abortions. Is legal abortion really safe?
According to the Royal College of Obstetricians and Gynecologists in the UK, the immediate
physical complication rate from abortions is at least 11%, primarily infections that can
lead to a host of other problems including pain and infertility. With over 1.3
million abortions per year in the U.S., over 140,000 women
a year have immediate medical complications from abortion. This includes problems
such as: infection, uterine perforation, hemorrhaging, cervical trauma, and failed
abortion/ongoing pregnancy. These complications are serious enough that 20 or more
women die from legal abortions annually in the U.S. Beyond immediate complications,
abortion can lead to infertility, a serious long-term complication that often goes
undetected for many years. Abortion can also lead to complications in future
pregnancies including: premature birth, placenta previa, and ectopic pregnancy. Psychological and emotional
complications reported in a 1994 survey of women who had abortions and sought counseling
found that they experienced a range of problems including: increased use of drugs and/or
alcohol to deaden their pain, reoccurring insomnia and nightmares, eating disorders that
began after the abortion, suicidal feelings, and many even attempted suicide.
Various studies indicate that as many as 80-90% of women who aborted a pregnancy
ultimately regret their decision. The nation is now
recognizing the negative impact of abortion on women. According to a nationwide poll
conducted by Wirthlin Worldwide from September 24-27, 61% of respondents said
they felt abortion was "almost always a bad thing." The poll results
revealed that 64 percent of Americans know someone who has had an abortion. When
asked whether the abortion experience of the person they knew was positive or negative, 55
percent identified it as a negative experience overall. Abortion is not a convenient solution
to problems that should be kept legal, but a plague that should be made illegal to
save women from its serious negative consequences. William Beckman Executive Director Illinois Right to Life Committee 65 E. Wacker Place, Suite 800 Chicago, IL 60601 312-422-9300 beckman@illinoisrighttolife.org
Emboldened GOP ready to rock Roe November 10, 2004 (Chicago Sun-Times)As always, my children stood at the cardboard voting box with me last week and took turns using the punch pin to help me vote. My son chose to vote for Democratic senatorial candidate Barack Obama. That was a tough one for me. In my 25 years as a voter, there have been only a handful of candidates for whom I have voted proudly. I was very much looking forward to casting that ballot myself. But, in the interest of raising a future voter, I put aside my selfishness and let him punch the chad. My daughter chose to vote for John Kerry for president. Fine with me. I wanted my vote cast for him -- or, more correctly, against George W. Bush -- but I wasn't all that keen on doing the deed myself. That little family scene might tell us something about why Democrats failed last week to oust a president who has taken us into war on a lie, racked up a record federal budget deficit and chipped away at the Constitution in the name of national security and religion. Our candidate simply couldn't energize the electorate. Bush, however, chooses to see his 3.5-million vote margin as a mandate for moral action in a country that hemorrhaged Republican red on election night. Now, the issues that barely got a hearing during this campaign are jumping to the top of Bush's to-do list. He is moving ahead with environmental changes, plans a sweeping tax code revamp, and if his most conservative supporters have their say, will appoint a new Supreme Court that would overturn Roe vs. Wade, the landmark ruling that made abortion legal in America. That prospect ought to strike fear into the hearts of women everywhere, according to Anu Kumar. The former Evanston resident now is executive director of Ipas, a Chapel Hill, N.C.-based nonprofit that works to prevent unsafe abortions and increase access to reproductive health services around the world. She knows what happens when abortion is outlawed. "[T]he more barriers there are to safe abortion, the more dangerous it is for women," Kumar said. Around the world, nearly 40 women undergo an unsafe abortion every minute -- some in countries where abortion is legal but limited. Nearly 70,000 women die each year from the complications of the dangerous procedures. In 1965 women died here, too: 193 deaths, 17 percent of all maternal deaths, were abortion-related in those bad old days, Kumar said. It's not so far-fetched to think that it might happen again. There are about 3 million unplanned or unwanted pregnancies each year in America. In a post-Roe world, wealthy women still will be able to afford safe abortions. But poor women may turn to a coat-hanger or bleach for a self-induced abortion. Fearing such disasters, Planned Parenthood Federation of America has formed a "Post-Roe Service Delivery Task Force" to figure out how to provide abortions if federal law should ban them. The group is exploring the possibility of setting up clinics along the U.S. border in Canada, on Native American reservations and on ships anchored offshore, and it is developing a strategy to ensure that "safe states," such as Illinois, stay safe. Scariest of all, the task force has urged doctors to get training in how to deal with a medical crisis all but eradicated from our country: infection, uncontrolled bleeding and other life-threatening complications of botched abortions. Illinois is considered to be a "safe state" but, as Terry Cosgrove, executive director of Personal PAC, said at the group's annual awards lunch: "We're only one election away from losing choice." It didn't happen last week, but anti-choice activists did pick up a few seats in the Illinois House of Representatives and one seat in the Illinois Senate. Steve Trombley, president and chief executive officer of Planned Parenthood Chicago Area, said he believes Illinois will remain a "safe state" for women seeking abortion. In a post-Roe world, "The role we play would become increasingly important, if not critical." Likewise, the rookie Sen. Obama and veteran Sen. Kerry, who returns to his old job now that he's lost the general election, will play a critical role in fighting Bush's "moral" agenda for the next four years. Long live the filibuster.
|